Connect with us
ANE Scholarship
Categories:
X

Entertainment

Ed Sheeran and co-writers awarded nearly £1,000,000 in legal fees after Shape Of You copyright win

Published

on

Kindly share this post:
Ed Sheeran and co-writers awarded nearly £1,000,000 in legal fees after Shape Of You copyright win

The songwriter denied being a ‘magpie’ and stealing ideas from other musicians.

Ed Sheeran and his co-songwriters have been awarded over £900,000 in legal costs after winning their High Court copyright trial over the hit Shape Of You earlier this year.

At a trial in March, the singer and co-writers, Snow Patrol’s John McDaid and producer Steven McCutcheon, faced accusations that their track ripped off a 2015 song by Sami Chokri and Ross O’Donoghue.

HEY! Download & Install The New ANE Android App To Your Device
Hello!! Have you heard about the deadly virus called Coronavirus? No? See What It Is & How To Prevent It Here. Also Stay Connected & Get Latest Updates On Coronavirus Here. Please be safe! We LOVE You.



However, Mr Justice Zacaroli concluded Mr Sheeran ‘neither deliberately nor subconsciously’ copied a phrase in the song.

Mr Sheeran, his co-authors and their music companies originally launched legal proceedings in May 2018, asking the High Court to declare they had not infringed Mr Chokri and Mr O’Donoghue’s copyright.

Two months later, Mr Chokri – a grime artist who performs under the name Sami Switch – and Mr O’Donoghue issued their own claim for ‘copyright infringement, damages and an account of profits in relation to the alleged infringement’.

ANE

ANE Scholarship

The pair had alleged that an ‘Oh I’ hook in Shape Of You is ‘strikingly similar’ to an ‘Oh Why’ refrain in their own track

Ed Sheeran said ‘baseless’ claims are harmful, and he now records all his songwriting sessions

Ed Sheeran said ‘baseless’ claims are harmful, and he now records all his songwriting sessions.

But in his previous judgment, Mr Justice Zacaroli concluded: ‘Mr Sheeran had not heard Oh Why and in any event that he did not deliberately copy the Oh I phrase from the Oh Why hook.’

He dismissed the counterclaim and granted a declaration to Mr Sheeran and his fellow songwriters that they had not infringed the copyright in Oh Why.

Following the ruling, lawyers for Mr Chokri and Mr O’Donoghue had said that Mr Sheeran and the other claimants should pay their own legal costs, claiming they had failed to provide documents and demonstrated ‘awkwardness and opacity’.

However, in a ruling on Tuesday, Mr Justice Zacaroli said that the lesser-known songwriters should pay the claimants’ legal costs, ordering an interim payment of £916,200.

A further hearing is expected to assess and finalise the sums.

Sami Chokri released Oh Why in 2015

Sami Chokri released Oh Why in 2015.

 

Ross O’Donoghue also claimed the song infringes parts of one of their songs

Ross O’Donoghue also claimed the song infringes parts of one of their songs.

‘I consider it is appropriate that the claimants’ success is reflected in an order that their costs are paid by the defendants, without reduction save for that which is made as part of the process of detailed assessment,’ Mr Justice Zacaroli said.

The judge dismissed arguments that the defendants would have changed their approach to the case if some documents and explanations about how Shape Of You was written had been provided earlier.

Mr Justice Zacaroli said: ‘None of the disclosure or explanations, once provided to the defendants, caused them to alter their approach at all.

‘Instead, they not only maintained their attack on Mr Sheeran but broadened it by asserting that he was a “magpie” who habitually misappropriated song ideas from other writers.’

During the 11-day trial in central London, Mr Sheeran – who said the trial had a great impact on his mental health – denied he ‘borrows’ ideas from unknown songwriters without acknowledgement and insisted he ‘always tried to be completely fair’ in crediting people who contribute to his albums.

In a video message after the ruling in April, Mr Sheeran said: ‘Claims like this are way too common now and have become a culture where a claim is made with the idea that a settlement will be cheaper than taking it to court, even if there is no basis for the claim, and it’s really damaging to the songwriting industry.’

The Lego House hitmaker confessed that ‘lawsuits are not a pleasant experience’ and he hopes ‘baseless claims like this can be avoided’ in the future.

‘This really does have to end,’ he said.

The A Team singer later revealed that he now records all of his songwriting sessions for protection.

If people try to make claims about him later down the line, he can tell them to ‘watch the footage’ and prove his innocence.

Mr Sheeran is currently on tour with his latest album and is also settling into life as a new dad again after welcoming a second daughter with wife Cherry Seaborn.


Get More Stories Like This On: Facebook: @AllNaijaEntertainment, Twitter: @AllNaijaEntertainment

Don’t Miss!

Join "ANE sabi" clique

Don't miss a thing, get ogbonge ANE latest updates to fuel your conversation daily.




Latest Exchange Rate

Donate To ANE!


Mind buying a coffee to support us here at All Naija Entertainment?. Yes?

Donate Now
Woman found dead in debris of Birmingham house explosion
News2 hours ago

Woman found dead in debris of Birmingham house explosion

News3 hours ago

2023 presidency: Why Kwankwaso can’t be running mate to Peter Obi – Jibrin

Bola Tinubu
News3 hours ago

Those Doubting Tinubu’s Credentials Should Go To Court – Farouk Aliyu

News3 hours ago

Tinubu, Atiku Can’t Fix Nigeria – Ango Abdullahi

News3 hours ago

I Will Get You A Good Running Mate – Gbajabiamila Tells Tinubu

Youth group commends Soludo over Anambra 2022 revised budget
News3 hours ago

My First 100 Days In Office Has Been Bumpy, Challenging – Soludo

Why I Wear #54 - Dwayne The Rock Johnson Reveals
Celebrities3 hours ago

Why I Wear #54 – Dwayne The Rock Johnson Reveals

Ukrainian refugee whose partner left wife for her says ‘I didn’t steal anyone’
General4 hours ago

Ukrainian refugee whose partner left wife for her says ‘I didn’t steal anyone’

Fireboy: Nigeria dominating Afrobeats because we make the best music
Entertainment5 hours ago

2022 BET Awards: Afrobeats shines as Pheelz and Fireboy performs

Tems
Entertainment5 hours ago

2022 BET Awards: Tems makes history, wins award

Glastonbury clean-up begins following Kendrick Lamar’s powerful closing set
Entertainment7 hours ago

Glastonbury clean-up begins following Kendrick Lamar’s powerful closing set

Buffer zones would give peace of mind for those accessing abortion clinics – MSP
News7 hours ago

Buffer zones would give peace of mind for those accessing abortion clinics – MSP

World leaders join forces to condemn US abortion ruling
News7 hours ago

World leaders join forces to condemn US abortion ruling

Google tells workers they can relocate 'without justification' following Supreme Court decision
Technology7 hours ago

Google tells workers they can relocate ‘without justification’ following Supreme Court decision

Fireboy: Nigeria dominating Afrobeats because we make the best music
Entertainment15 hours ago

Fireboy: Nigeria dominating Afrobeats because we make the best music

Waje, Phyno, Asake perform at free concert in Abuja PVC drive
Entertainment16 hours ago

Waje, Phyno, Asake perform at free concert in Abuja PVC drive (PHOTOS)

Sports18 hours ago

Why Sadio Mane Left Liverpool – Agent Reveals

Entertainment18 hours ago

“Why Many Artistes Find It Hard To Handle Fame” – Singer, Orezi Speaks, Reveals His Most Embarrassing Moment

News19 hours ago

Ekweremadu: Immigration Probes Organ Donor’s Passport

News19 hours ago

Ekweremadu: Ohanaeze Writes UK Embassy, Issues Warning To Blackmailers

News19 hours ago

Northern Govs’ Interest In Tinubu Not Genuine, May Ditch Him For Atiku – Akintoye

Bola Tinubu
News19 hours ago

2023: Some ‘Unknown Persons’ Stole My Academic Certificates – Tinubu Tells INEC

Jack-Rich Asks Buhari, Others to Prepare for Bleak Economy in 2023
News19 hours ago

Jack-Rich Asks Buhari, Others to Prepare for Bleak Economy in 2023

King Sunny Ade
Entertainment20 hours ago

Woman claims Sunny Ade is her father, details years-long paternity dispute

Tambuwal’s foreign scholarship for medical degrees produces 55 graduands
Education20 hours ago

Tambuwal’s foreign scholarship for medical degrees produces 55 graduands

Ejeviome Otobo, missing ex-Nigerian diplomat, found dead in US
News20 hours ago

Ejeviome Otobo, missing ex-Nigerian diplomat, found dead in US

Central chest pain shouldn’t be ignored, could be early sign of heart attack –Cardiologist
Technology21 hours ago

Central chest pain shouldn’t be ignored, could be early sign of heart attack –Cardiologist

Snoring shouldn’t be ignored, can trigger impotence in men – surgeon
Technology21 hours ago

Snoring shouldn’t be ignored, can trigger impotence in men – surgeon

Delta police arrest man for beheading son
News21 hours ago

Delta police arrest man for beheading son

How NASA might protect tomorrow's astronauts from deep space radiation
Technology21 hours ago

How NASA might protect tomorrow’s astronauts from deep space radiation

Ousmane Dembele
Sports22 hours ago

Ousmane Dembele disappointed by Chelsea offer as Raheem Sterling approach hampers deal

Manchester United respond to claims Cristiano Ronaldo could make Chelsea transfer
General23 hours ago

Manchester United respond to claims Cristiano Ronaldo could make Chelsea transfer

Actor Itele breaks silence as his secret affair with actress, Debankee is exposed (Details)
Entertainment23 hours ago

Actor Itele breaks silence as his secret affair with actress, Debankee is exposed (Details)

“He kept his father in an awkward position” Pete Edochie’s ‘sad’ look as he finally meets his grandson gets many talking
Entertainment24 hours ago

“He kept his father in an awkward position” Pete Edochie’s ‘sad’ look as he finally meets his grandson gets many talking

“Living my best life” Eniola Badmus peppers haters as she goes on vacation in style
Entertainment24 hours ago

Living my best life possible Eniola Badmus lashes out at detractors as she enjoys a luxurious vacation.

“You are such a humble superstar” Mo Bimpe eulogises husband, Lateef Adedimeji as he bags an award in Vienna, Austria
Entertainment1 day ago

“You are such a humble superstar” Mo Bimpe eulogises husband, Lateef Adedimeji as he bags an award in Vienna, Austria

At 35 years old, actress Caroline Danjuma still shines (Photos)
Entertainment1 day ago

At 35 years old, actress Caroline Danjuma still shines (Photos)

5 American celebrities who explained why they don't want children
Entertainment1 day ago

5 American celebrities who explained why they don’t want children

Can you bring your own food and drink to Glastonbury 2022?
Entertainment1 day ago

Can you bring your own food and drink to Glastonbury 2022?

Lily Allen ‘overwhelmed’ after performing with Olivia Rodrigo at Glastonbury after almost three years sobriety
Entertainment1 day ago

Lily Allen ‘overwhelmed’ after performing with Olivia Rodrigo at Glastonbury after almost three years sobriety

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories7 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 13)

Done deal at Stamford Bridge after hours of negotiation for the transfer of a world-class player
Sports6 days ago

Done deal at Stamford Bridge after hours of negotiation for the transfer of a world-class player

All You Need to Know About Katrin Zytomierska Whom Her Instagram Post Of Gerard Pique With New Mystery Girl Goes Viral
Celebrities5 days ago

All You Need to Know About Katrin Zytomierska Whom Her Instagram Post Of Gerard Pique With New Mystery Girl Goes Viral

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories6 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 15)

Money Heist: Korea – Joint Economic Area
Movie Subtitles2 days ago

DOWNLOAD Complete Money Heist: Korea Season 1 (S01) – Joint Economic Area Subtitles File [English SRT] 2022 (Episode 1-6)

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 16)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Complete Episodes)

SADE's HEART TALE by Amah's Heart _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] SADE’S HEART TALE (Complete Episodes)

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories6 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 14)

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 17)

Journey Band
Music7 days ago

[Music] Journey – Open Arms

FLIRTATIOUS story by Opeyemi Ojerinde Akintunde _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] FLIRTATIOUS (Episode 40)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Complete Episodes)

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories4 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 19)

Music5 days ago

[Music] Drake, 21 Savage – Jimmy Cooks

SADE's HEART TALE by Amah's Heart _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] SADE’S HEART TALE (Episode 01)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 01)

BETTY AND THE BEAST by MIRIAM EDEM _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories4 days ago

[STORY] BETTY AND THE BEAST (Episode 18)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 11)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Final Episode 15)

SADE's HEART TALE by Amah's Heart _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories4 days ago

[STORY] SADE’S HEART TALE (Episode 02)

FLIRTATIOUS story by Opeyemi Ojerinde Akintunde _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories6 days ago

[STORY] FLIRTATIOUS (Episode 39)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 02)

Suraj Jagan & Sharman Joshi - Give Me Some Sunshine (3 Idiots)
Music5 days ago

[Music] Suraj Jagan & Sharman Joshi – Give Me Some Sunshine (3 Idiots)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 04)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 06)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 04)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 08)

Kizz Daniel Releases Sensational New Visuals To Hit Track "Buga" Ft Tekno Miles
Entertainment5 days ago

Kizz Daniel Releases Sensational New Visuals To Hit Track “Buga” Ft Tekno Miles (Directed by TG Omori)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 10)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 01)

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 03)

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 10)

Wizkid
Lyrics7 days ago

Kay Switch feat. Olamide & Wizkid – For Example (Remix) [Lyrics]

Jackie Chan
Celebrities5 days ago

YES, Jackie Chan Was Once A Porn Actor!

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 05)

Netflix seeks recruits for real-life ‘Squid Game’
Entertainment7 days ago

Squid Game Season 2 Cast, Story, Trailer, Release Date, Episodes, OTT Platform

THE PROPER MRS by Onyekachi Ikeh _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] THE PROPER MRS (Episode 09)

Two more mystery explosions in Russia send fireballs into the sky
News4 days ago

Two more mystery explosions in Russia send fireballs into the sky

I CHEATED ON MY WIFE Story _ AllNaijaEntertainment
ANE Stories5 days ago

[STORY] I CHEATED ON MY WIFE (Episode 03)

ANE Billboard Hots!