Connect with us


Agbakoba, Quakers Differ On China Loan “Sovereignty Clause”

The Terrorist!



TWO senior lawyers have expressed divergent views on the ‘sovereignty clause’ in the $400m commercial loan agreement between Nigeria and China.

Hello!! Have you heard about the deadly virus called Coronavirus? No? See What It Is & How To Prevent It Here. Also Stay Connected & Get Latest Updates On Coronavirus Here. Please be safe! We LOVE You.

The clause has pitted critics and the National Assembly against the Federal Executive Council (FEC).

The opponents argue that the clause ousted the nation’s sovereignty, should Nigeria fail to repay the loan.

They explain that such a clause should not have been included in a commercial agreement.

But, a former President of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Dr. Olisa Agbakoba (SAN), said there is nothing to worry about.

He dismissed the claim that such a clause ousted the country’s immunity.

Another lawyer Mr. Norrison Quakers (SAN) disagreed with Agbakoba.

According to him, the clause “is an error” which should not have been inserted.

The loan pact was signed by the Federal Ministry of Finance on behalf of Nigeria and the Export-Import Bank of China on September 5, 2018.

It will fund the Nigeria National Information and Communication Technology Infrastructure Backbone Phase II Projects.

The contentious clause states: “The borrower hereby irrevocably waives any immunity on the grounds of sovereign or otherwise for itself or its property in connection with any arbitration proceeding pursuant to Article 8(5), thereof with the enforcement of any arbitral award pursuant thereto, except for the military assets and diplomatic assets.”

The ministers clarified that the lawmakers must have misconstrued the concepts of international diplomatic immunity and commercial immunity.

Agbakoba agreed, adding that the appropriate term for the clause is “a waiver of immunity clause” and that it is a standard contractual provision.

He said: “There is a lot of confusion, hot air about the sovereign immunity clause. There is nothing about a sovereign immunity clause.

“The standard clause that is introduced when two sovereigns are doing business – like China and Nigeria – or a non-sovereign and a sovereign are doing business is for the sovereign debtor, such as Nigeria, to have her credit assessed.

“Now, look at Nigeria or Africa’s credit rating generally. Africa’s credit rating is sub-optimal. No bank in Nigeria will give a loan unless there are assurances of it being repaid.

“If you’re the governor of a state, the bank manager will ask: ‘If I give you a loan, will you not invoke your immunity?’ and you say no. Then the manager will say, ‘Let us have it in the contract that in the event you default, you will not invoke your immunity.’

“So, it’s actually a waiver of immunity clause, not a sovereign immunity clause.”

The senior advocate observed that the waiver of immunity clause was at work recently when Zambia lost assets to China after it defaulted on repaying a loan.

Agbakoba said: “Zambia was not able to use sovereign immunity to avoid debt repayment.

“If you have good standing internationally, for instance, America will not waive its sovereign immunity because America is good for credit. Unfortunately, few African countries are not good for credit. So, it is the credit worthiness issue that is the problem.”

On the controversy triggered by the clause, Agbakoba said: “When the National Assembly began to make all the noise, it beat me hollow; they absolutely got it wrong. There’s nothing like sovereign immunity clause.

“It’s a contractual clause that simply says ‘if you don’t pay, we’ll go after your assets.”

Quakers said: “No country will willingly cede its sovereignty to another country on the basis of a contractual arrangement.”

He, however, observed that the agreement seemed to put China in a position of power over Nigeria, Quakers said: “As far as I am concerned, I haven’t seen the agreement itself, but I’ve read some extracts here and there concerning the clause.

“The only thing I see there is like an unfair contract, a situation where someone has an upper hand, an edge over you. By saying ‘Ok, you want this facility, I’ll give it to you, but in the unlikely event of a default, you will not define assets that I will hold on to, to liquidate the debts.”

Agbakoba said the government should have taken time to think through the deal carefully.

“That agreement should also have been subjected to some scrutiny, not necessarily by government lawyers, but even by those in the private sector, particularly in commercial practice ‘Please look at this, what do you think and then advise the government accordingly.’”

He said the contract appeared to give China discretion to pick which Nigerian asset to “hold on to for the purpose of liquidating the debt…

“That, for me, is the error in terms of the agreement. It’s actually an error,” Quakers added.

Get More Stories Like This On: Facebook: @AllNaijaEntertainment, Twitter: @AllNaijaEntertainment
Reach us on WhatsApp via: +2348104471989

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don’t Miss!

Join "ANE sabi" clique

Don't miss a thing, get ogbonge ANE latest updates to fuel your conversation daily.

Latest Exchange Rate

Donate To ANE!

Mind buying a coffee to support us here at All Naija Entertainment?. Yes?

Donate Now
Ice Prince
Lyrics10 mins ago

Ice Prince – More [Lyrics]

Ice Prince
Music12 mins ago

[Music] Ice Prince – More

News39 mins ago

36 States Sue FG, Demand Funding Of State Courts

Lyrics47 mins ago

Dagrin – Ghetto Dreams (feat. Sossick) [Lyrics]

Music49 mins ago

[Music] Dagrin – Ghetto Dreams (feat. Sossick)

Lyrics1 hour ago

Dagrin – If I Die [Lyrics]

Music1 hour ago

[Music] Dagrin – If I Die

Technology2 hours ago

Facebook Critics Start Rival, Independent ‘Oversight Board’

News2 hours ago

Ondo Election: INEC Warns Electoral Officers Against Compromise

Nigeria Labour Congress NLC
News2 hours ago

Strike: Aviation Unions Back Labour, Direct Members To Withdraw Services From Monday

Technology2 hours ago

Senegalese Fintech PayDunya Startup Expands To Two More Countries

News2 hours ago

Nigerian Govt To Deport 10 Egyptians, Seven Sri-lankans

Rotimi Akeredolu
News2 hours ago

Ondo Guber Election 2020: “Ondo Is Not Rivers, Steer Clear” – Akeredolu Tells Wike

News2 hours ago

Strike: Governors set up committee to meet FG, labour over petrol price, electricity tariff hikes

IPAC logo
News2 hours ago

Yobe Local Council Election: IPAC Rejects Postponement

Nigeria Labour Congress NLC
News2 hours ago

Strike: Again, Court Restrains NLC, TUC From Planned Strike Over Fuel Price Hike

Nyesom Wike
News2 hours ago

Wike Reveals Why Edo Election Was Adjudged Credible

Luis Suarez Barcelona
Sports2 hours ago

Luis Suarez: Leo Messi Comes For Barcelona Board Again!

PDP Logo
News11 hours ago

Ondo Election: PDP cautions INEC on use of Z-pad for Ondo guber poll

Education11 hours ago

School Resumption: Kano govt reveals why it is yet to reopen schools

ANE Billboard Hots!

Join "ANE sabi" clique

Don't miss a thing, get ogbonge ANE latest updates to fuel your conversation daily.

Copyright © All Naija Entertainment.